I’m struggling to keep the momentum up this last month for the Mount TBR Challenge 2017, but I’m very pleased to announce that I’ve finally knocked over Greenglass House by Kate Milford which has been on my TBR list since I pre-ordered it in 2014. Never mind that it took two years to arrive, but that’s another story. Let’s crack on.
Ten Second Synopsis:
Milo and his parents are settling in for Christmas at their historical inn when a collection of strangers arrive unannounced for a prolonged stay. At first it seems the travellers aren’t connected but after Milo and his friend Meddy begin investigating, it appears that all of these disparate people are at Greenglass House for the same reason.
Time on the TBR Shelf:
Technically since mid-2014, physically since October 2016. See below for details.
I first put this on pre-order at the Book Depository back in mid 2014, when it was originally released. I put the pre-order on the paperback, which was releasing in the middle of 2015 because I’m cheap and I figured I could wait that long. Then the release date got pushed out to September of 2015. I was tetchy, but accepted this. THEN the release date got pushed out to September 2016! It arrived in October 2016.
Reason I haven’t read it yet:
Because it only arrived seven months ago. Obvs. Also, it’s quite hefty, so I had to
find make time to fit it in.
- Greenglass House is a hefty, prolonged mystery. The mystery is drawn out and is also quite cerebral, since the players in the mystery are confined to one house in bad weather. The story does has some echoes of the golden age of crime fiction about it, but since no crime has been committed (at least at first), it also has the feel of a fun, imaginative adventure game. I’ve heard it compared to The Westing Game and there is definitely a similarity in the plotting, but Greenglass House doesn’t have the urgency or high stakes of that book and so is a bit cosier overall.
- Tabletop roleplay gaming is a big feature of the story, with Milo and Meddy taking on characters as they solve the mystery. Milo’s blackjack/escaladeur character, Negret, allows Milo to think outside the box and take risks that Milo himself normally wouldn’t, while Meddy’s Sirin, a scholiast, or invisible angel type character has a great significance to the story that didn’t strike me until close to the end of the book.
- Because there are only two child characters in a house of adults, the book avoids annoying middle grade tropes and gets down to brass tacks as the kids use all their cunning and game-smarts to uncover the adults’ secrets.
- The adult characters tell stories throughout the book, so we are treated to stories within the greater story and you can be sure each of these stories drops some clues about the adults who tell them and secrets they might be hiding.
- The story, house and myths about the area feel like they could really be true, which adds a sense of realism to the magical realism.
- Milo’s parents are ordinary people – hooray! It’s so rare to have parents in middle grade stories that are (a) present (b) completely normal (as opposed to being gods, magicians, spies or generally not what their children think they are) and (c) involved in their child’s life. I also liked that Milo is adopted, which plays something of a role in the story, but isn’t the big clincher – just a part of who he is.
- The book is set at Christmas, but has very little to do with Christmas, and so is a perfect choice for when you want that Christmas time feeling without having to actually read about Christmas.
Less Impressive Bits:
- Greenglass House is a hefty, prolonged mystery. That means that the pacing is quite slow and discoveries are rationed out over the course of the book. While I enjoyed the read and was absorbed throughout, I won’t be picking up the sequel straight away. I’ll need some time to decompress before I become sucked into the second mystery in the series.
- There is a twist toward the end of the book that I didn’t see coming and although I came to terms with it reasonably quickly, I felt a little betrayed that the author had taken such a route when the rest of the book seemed so authentic and grounded (barring the smugglers, strangers, thieves, spies and customs officials). I’ll have to wait and see how it pans out in the second book before I make too many judgments though.
On reflection, was this worth buying?
Yes, because it is highly unlikely that I would have ever borrowed such a hefty book from the library. To balance that out though, I’m not sorry I had to wait so long before getting to it.
Where to now for this tome?
The permanent shelf…for now.
I’m also submitting Greenglass House for the Popsugar Reading Challenge 2017 in category #35: a book set in a hotel. You can check out my progess toward all my 2017 challenges here.
Until next time,