From Poignant to Peppy: A Double Haiku Review…


Good morning to you, loyal friend of the shelf! Or alternately, if this is your first visit, welcome soon-to-be loyal friend of the shelf! It is Mad Martha with you today and I am delighted to be sharing with you two very different illustrated books for young readers.  One is poignant, grave and yet abundant with signs of hope, while the other is peppy, cheerful and abundant with moments of unexpected quirkiness.  I was lucky enough to receive print copies of today’s books from Book Guild Publishing for review – many thanks!

Let us begin with poignancy, shall we?

West of the West Wind is the third in a series of short story collections by Norwegian author Nils-Johan Jorgensen that feature folk tales for children aged nine plus.  This collection is comprised of three stories that all revolve around hope and endurance in the face of hardship.  The Library, the first story in this edition, follows a young boy who tries to rescue some books that are to be burned by the Nazi occupying forces.  In his mission, the boy discovers that allies can be found amongst supposed enemies, and that as long as there are those prepared to demonstrate courage, the written word will endure.  The Wolves is also set during World War II and in it three young siblings and their (acquired) canine friends are confronted with the consequences of showing love and kindness during a time of distrust and violence.  Finally, The Silence of the Sail, introduces the young sailor Thomas as he attempts to forge a new path in the new world and leave his small island home in Norway behind.

west of the west wind

Books in a satchel,

Unlikely friends; dreams pursued.

Out of darkness, light.

West of the West Wind was my first encounter with Jorgensen’s work for children (or indeed, adults!) and after reading this tome I am very interested to seek out the prior two in the series, North of the North Wind (based on Nordic fairy tales) and East of the East Wind (modern-day fables featuring oriental themes).  The book is only short, at 64 pages, but it certainly packs in some highly emotional content.  From an adult reader’s point of view, the stories revolve around heartbreak, loss and the pervasive fear that looms when something or someone that we hold dear is threatened with destruction.  But alongside these emotions are the sparks of hope and rebellion that are woven through the story, from the boy in The Library, desperate to save just one more book from the pyre, to the little family that is forged in the mountain hut in The Wolves, and the decision to break out of one’s ancestral mould in The Silence of the Sail.  I suspect that young readers may not appreciate the nuances of emotion in the same depth as adult readers would, but in reading, or being read to from these stories, they would certainly understand the sense of integrity, and the choice to act against opposition and fear that is common to the characters in all three stories.

The line drawings that appear throughout the book are just beautiful and perfectly compliment the subdued atmosphere of the stories.  My favourite of the three stories was The Wolves, because of the lighter tone that coloured most of the story.  The Library however, has the most favourable ending of the three.  The Silence of the Sail left me a bit melancholy, and the ending was rather abrupt (in a few senses!) which jarred a little.  Overall though, this was a thought-provoking and memorable read, dealing with a period in history that we often think young children may not be able to handle.  Of course, the ability to process the negative experiences of death, separation and war that are featured here will vary from child to child, so it may be useful for parents or teachers planning on sharing this book to consider ways in which the stories might lead to deeper discussions about the content.

West of the West Wind was released in March.

Now on to the peppy!

The double delight that is One Red Heart & Mindy’s Birthday by Nao A. Weaver is certainly something different from your average picture book for kids.  The book contains two little stories accented with quirky illustrations that make you look twice.  One Red Heart is about a little mouse who is given a little red heart as a gift.  The story proceeds as a counting adventure, with the mouse gathering friends around him until all they all come together to make music with their ten colourful hearts.  In Mindy’s Birthday, a surprise party is afoot and a host of odd little munchkins spend their day making decorations, baking cakes and generally preparing a birthday of epic proportions.  The effort turns out to be worth it as the guests party on into the wee small hours before curling up together in a “sweet-scented flower”. As you do.

 one red heart

The word “whimsy” is

often overused these days,

but accurate here.

I don’t like to describe things as whimsical, because I think the word is getting a bit trite and cliched, but really, there’s no other word to describe Weaver’s work.  Well, actually I could probably use odd, or unusual or cheerful or playful or fanciful….okay, so I probably should have thought a bit harder before I went with whimsical, but it’s done now.  In any case, this book has a very original look about it.  The colourful line drawings really add to the overall feel of the stories, as the text is sparse, but I would have liked the illustrations to be bigger so I could better appreciate the detail in them.  In some cases the text, though sparse, was quite helpful, as it helped me to figure out what was going on.

While examining the pictures and the text together, the book reminded me of nothing so much as a child’s unexpected response to an artistic instruction.  For example, I know that in response to the line “Don’t be late!” I would probably draw something mundane. Like a watch. Or an admonishing finger.  Not Weaver. Check this out:


A bunch of jaunty creatures riding a luck dragon (or related genus).  And might I just add, commuting by public transport would no doubt become a lot more popular if people got to travel by luck dragon (or related genus).  Take note, Brisbane City Council!

Weaver is a Japanese author (as well as artist and illustrator) and like many things that come out of Japan, pop culture wise, this book may have you thinking, “Well, that was a bit strange, but I liked it”.  I was certainly thinking that as I turned the pages.  With that in mind, I suspect that this book will find its niche with those who like their stories to be a springboard into hitherto unexplored mindscapes of the imagination, rather than a linear story with a familiar characters and a reasonably predictable beginning, middle and end.

One Red Heart & Mindy’s Birthday was released in February.

I also feel compelled to mention that it would fit perfectly into category four of the Small Fry Safari Kid Lit Readers Challenge – a book with someone’s name in the title, or indeed, category six – a book with something precious in the title.  Similarly, West of the West Wind could fit into category one – a book with something relating to Safari in the title.  To find out more about the challenge, click on the button below, then sign up so we can welcome you aboard the Safari bus!

small fryUntil we meet again friends and newcomers,

Mad Martha

Follow on Bloglovin

my read shelf:
Bruce Gargoyle's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)